This week's activity was especially pertinent for me in my role as Grade 1/2 Technology Specialist. Last year, I worried about many of the issues touched upon in these scenarios. Since I work with much younger kids (and for many, this is their first school exposure to the internet) I feel a particular responsibility to ensure safe use, understanding of copyright, and other issues. Fortunately, I had no major issues last year but I think technology, wonderful as it may be, has introduced a variety of new challenges educators face.
Here is my response to Scenario 3 (Anonymous Blogging - Ms. Gifford and the inappropriate use of blogs)
Since Blogger is blocked for elementary age kids in MV, this scenario hit home for me. So far, my blogging has been a matter of me posting things that kids can respond to. I would like to let them create their own blogs but am concerned about the exact issues Ms. Gifford has faced. One thing that I want to do better next year is keep the parents informed about what I am doing. I felt like I did a pretty good job of helping the kids understand internet safety and privacy issues but I did not include the parents in this. Consequently, it was the parents who helped the kids post photos (of the kids) on their websites, something I absolutely did not allow because of safety. Parents also helped their kids embed copyrighted things into websites. Oops. It was an easy problem to fix since I have administrative access to kids' accounts but it showed that parents didn't really understand what they needed to know.
Although I know there are other blog platforms that elementary aged kids can, I am still hesitant for kids to each create their own blog in Technology. I am also not sure what educational objective I would attach it to since I don't teach reading or math (or social studies, etc.) to kids. For this upcoming year, I thought I might start by setting up a "class" blog for each class and blogging together once a week when I see the kids for Technology.
Ultimately, what I discovered last year, is that 1st and 2nd graders can be a bit naive in their use of technology. They are not quite sophisticated enough (yet) to use it as a weapon (ie - bullying) and in the same hand, they don't always "get" how unsafe it is to do things that we talk about as being unsafe (such as posting their address or pictures of themselves.) As I said, I feel a tremendous sense of responsibility when I work with primary aged kids in Technology. It's a great new world, but one that needs to be handled with care when it comes to kids.
Scenario 5 (Email Complication)
Okay, I actually laughed as I read this scenario because this was pretty much my life as a first year Technology teacher last year. Things were ALWAYS going wrong - even when I prepared and double checked and did everything I thought I could possibly do before teaching a lesson. One of my personal examples is when I went to show first graders how to access their home folders. I went through the lesson beforehand, by myself in the lab, using the Smartboard, and trying to anticipate everything that could go wrong. Finding your home folder can be a really complicated situation for first graders because there are a lot of steps and a lot of words - and first graders can't always read. I thought I was totally prepared and when I finally had the chance to actually teach it to my first class, I discovered that the platform on the teacher computer looks entirely different than the platform on the kids' computers.
My solution to a complete Technology lesson meltdown has been to either: 1. Stop the lesson and do something else. I had a set of back-up plans for just such occasions 2. Have the kids read picture books (always had a basket of those available) while I showed a few "teacher" kids how to do the assignment, then let them teach others while I circulated around.
For my own personal scenario above, I had the kids read picture books while I trained about six kids in, who then trained the others. This worked for my first class and then I had time to figure out how to do it differently with my second class.
I would love to be able to say that you can prepare for everything and there will be no problems, but I've discovered there are just too many factors with technology to be able to anticipate it all. You need to be incredibly flexible and able to change "on a dime." I had situations where I had a lesson prepared that utilized the internet and the internet would go down just as we were starting the lesson - or I would come in to the lab to discover that the class before me had done things to the computers so that my kids couldn't use them properly - or the Smartboard or teacher computer would not work. I think those moments were teachable times for the kids as well. They were able to see how I handled frustrating circumstances and also learn to be flexible right along with me.